I may try flattening it a bit and see if it looks better. Viewing angle is everything and some of the photos I used for reference were not from directly side-on.
I have tried using the glass tutorial...and i think it turned out pretty good (great tutorial). I have attached a picture of my old glass look and the new one (which i think i'll keep using).
Jarink could you just go over in detail the reflection bit because I'm confused how you've done that. The shadow and highlighting bit looks really confusing. Don't get how you got that kind of shape for the shadow etc... Thanks.
The shape for the shadow and highlights will depend entirely on the shape of the original part. No big surprise there, I guess. If you look at the photos I posted, you want to look at the reflections if the light fixtures and other stuff to get clues about the shape and how it affects light.
The trick is to make a hard edge on one side (towards the shiniest parts) and fade the other way. The hard edge is what gives it the glossy look.